
The above design can be attributed to the Coleman website of New Zealand. I could not find the designers name, though. The ad contains brief information for who and what Coleman is. They are a outdoor and camping gear supplies company, dedicated to providing consumers with a more comfortable outdoors experience.
https://www.google.com/url?sa=i&url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.colemannz.co.nz%2F&psig=AOvVaw1YJ5849SG6rbCPBIULVjiu&ust=1584678574554000&source=images&cd=vfe&ved=0CAMQjB1qFwoTCNjl7O_ZpegCFQAAAAAdAAAAABAJ

Original ad analyses
Design: Contrast (Purple Pinkish) – The color contrast of cools and warms of the white, blues, yellows, and greens really fit well together. The typography contrasts through the multiple chosen typeface.
Repetition (Light Blue) – The main repetition used here is with the drawn on designs near the typeface.
Alignment (Light Green) – Alignment is mainly horizontal, but with some diagonal themes as well.
Proximity (Yellow) – The Typeface and the drawn designs are very close together with each other, yet some distance from the photo. The people in the photo are just a little ways off from the tent to show they are enjoying themselves with their products.
Color: The colors used are like I said before, warm and cool mixed. This brings a good flow to the ad from text to photo.
Typography: There are three different typefaces used (not including the logo). They use script, sans-serif, and decorative mixed in there. They all flow and compliment each other well despite the differences.

This is the new ad I created as a reverse engineering of the other post.

NEW AD ANALYSES
Design: Contrast (Purple Pinkish) – As with the original, I made sure there was a mixture of warm and cool color contrasts.
Repetition (Light Blue) – I used the same design repetition with the lines and the stars.
Alignment (Light Green) – Alignments are the same, though on the opposite side of the ad.
Proximity (Yellow) – The proprieties are similar though a little more spread out as the type goes. And there are no human subjects in the photo.
Color: Warm and cool, blues, whites, a gray I added to the drawn designs, and the natural warms and cools of the photo.
Typography: I used 4 different types to go with the theme of every word used a different one since I added one. I used script and sans-serif. In retro-spec I realize I forgot to use the decorative.
Conclusion
The original ad and the new ad work well together in my opinion, as they bring the same elements to the advertisement. The message is similar, “Camp Better with Coleman” and “Enjoy the Night with Coleman” create an idea that the consumer will have a better camping experience with Coleman products. The ultimate design of the ad is similar enough. Though I will probably scale my new ad to more of the scale of the original when I complete the next project. Overall, I feel they work well for the same campaign.











